• Login
    • Join
  • Subscribe Free
    • Magazine
    • eNewsletter
    Checkout
    • Magazine
    • News
    • Exclusives
    • Labels & Packaging
    • Markets
    • Technology
    • Equipment
    • Supplies
    • Buyers' Guide
    • Events
    • Jobs
    • More
  • Magazine
  • News
  • Exclusives
  • Labels & Packaging
  • Markets
  • Technology
  • Equipment
  • Supplies
  • Buyers' Guide
  • Events
  • Jobs
  • Current / Back Issues
    Features
    Editorial
    Columns
    Digital Edition
    eNewsletter Archive
    Our Team
    Subscribe Now
    Advertise Now
    Top Features
    Controlling Static

    Spirits Labels

    Digital Finishing

    Metallic Effects Labels

    Narrow Web Profile: WS Packaging Group
    Breaking News
    Converter News
    European Label News
    Industry News
    Industry People
    M&A News
    New Products
    Expert's Opinion
    Live From Shows
    Top News
    Schreiner MediPharm develops smart label for Ypsomed

    ID Label celebrates 25 years

    Printeos Group goes digital with Durst Tau 330 RSC

    Technicote names new national sales director

    drupa 2020 to address packaging trends
    Beauty & Personal Care Labels
    Beer Labels
    Beverage Labels
    Flexible Packaging
    Folding Carton
    Food Labels
    Glue-Applied
    In-Mold
    Industrial Labels
    Medical Labels
    Pharmaceutical Labels
    Pressure Sensitive
    Prime Labels
    Promotional Labels
    Security Labels
    Shrink
    Smart Labels
    Specialty Labels
    Spirits Labels
    Wine Labels

    Schreiner MediPharm develops smart label for Ypsomed

    The e-commerce impact on warehouse and barcode labeling

    Schreiner ProTech launches enhanced anticounterfeiting label technology

    Lecta launches new Creaset HG HWS paper

    PragmatIC launches ConnectIC family
    Africa
    Asia
    Australia
    China
    Europe
    India
    Latin America
    Middle East
    North America

    Schreiner MediPharm develops smart label for Ypsomed

    Printeos Group goes digital with Durst Tau 330 RSC

    Technicote names new national sales director

    drupa 2020 to address packaging trends

    Yazoo Mills donates to local school's manufacturing program
    Flexography
    Digital Printing
    Prepress
    Finishing
    Sustainability

    The e-commerce impact on warehouse and barcode labeling

    Printeos Group goes digital with Durst Tau 330 RSC

    drupa 2020 to address packaging trends

    Yazoo Mills donates to local school's manufacturing program

    Hart Labels invests in Dantex PicoColour
    Digital Printers & Presses
    Flexo Presses
    Label Converting Equipment
    Label Finishing Equipment
    Prepress Equipment

    Printeos Group goes digital with Durst Tau 330 RSC

    Hart Labels invests in Dantex PicoColour

    Phoseon reflects on a year of new UV LED technology offerings

    iTek Packz opts for second Edale flexo press

    Colordyne introduces entry-level 1800 Series C
    Dies And Tooling
    Flexo Supplies
    Ink & Coatings
    Prepress Supplies
    Pressrooom Supplies
    Substrates

    Yazoo Mills donates to local school's manufacturing program

    GSE website providing ink management guides in Spanish

    Michelman showcases durable label technology at HP Indigo Global VIP Event

    Lecta launches new Creaset HG HWS paper

    UPM Raflatac opens new slitting and distribution terminal in South Africa
    All Companies
    Categories
    Company Profiles
    Label Converters
    Trade Associations
    Add New Company
    International Buyers Guide Companies
    RotoMetrics

    Flexo Export

    Siegwerk Environmental Inks

    Achem Industry America Inc.

    All Printing Resources Inc.
    Industry Events
    Webinars
    Live from Show Events
    • Magazine
      • Current & Past Issues
      • Features
      • Editorial
      • Columns
      • Digital Edition
      • eNewsletter Archive
      • Subscribe Now
      • Advertise Now
    • Breaking News
    • Buyers' Guide
      • All Companies
      • Categories
      • Company Profiles
      • Label Converters
      • Trade Associations
      • Add Your Company
    • Labels & Packaging
      • Beauty & Personal Care Labels
      • Beer Labels
      • Beverage Labels
      • Flexible Packaging
      • Folding Carton
      • Food Labels
      • Glue-Applied
      • In-Mold
      • Industrial Labels
      • Medical Labels
      • Pharmaceuticals Labels
      • Pressure Sensitive
      • Prime Labels
      • Promotional Labels
      • Security Labels
      • Shrink
      • Smart Labels
      • Speciality Labels
      • Spirits Labels
      • Wine Tables
    • Markets
      • Africa
      • Asia
      • Australia
      • China
      • Europe
      • India
      • Latin America
      • Middle East
      • North America
    • Equipment
      • Digital Printers & Presses
      • Flexo Presses
      • Label Converting Equipment
      • Label Fishing Equipment
    • Supplies
      • Dies And Tooling
      • Flexo Supplies
      • Ink & Coatings
      • Prepress Supplies
      • Pressrooom Supplies
      • Substrates
    • Online Exclusives
    • Slideshows
    • Experts Opinions
    • Videos
    • Podcasts
    • Infographics
    • Whitepapers
    • Events
      • Industry Events
      • Live from Show Events
      • Webinars
    • Jobs
    • Resources
      • Supplier Gallery
      • Literature Showcase
      • Homepage Showcase
    • About Us
      • About Us
      • Contact Us
      • Advertise With Us
      • Privacy Policy
      • Terms of Use
    Letters From The Earth

    Who owns the wind?

    Calvin Frost10.14.16
    Several weeks after I sent my last column to our editor, Steve Katz, a flurry of articles on energy appeared in three different newspapers.  I happened to catch them all, and they caused me to rethink my column on “circular economy.”  I’ll save that for the next issue.  These articles, you see, were so relevant to my earlier columns on the demise of coal and the growth of renewables. One was about wind energy in Wyoming, and it frustrated and eventually angered me.  Another was about the growth of wind and solar in Texas, a state that we have come to know for its oil and gas production. The third talked about the issues of replacing coal with renewables and suggested that America, Germany (the green of greenest country), China and others will have to move more slowly in the switch to renewables. The reason: the loss of jobs. Displacing thousands of coal miners will create more issues because of joblessness. Because of these three different accounts, I thought it fitting to add a post script column dedicated to Lester Brown and his work, The Great Transition.

    Brown is convinced that governments, industries and society support the transition because of the reduction of CO2 emissions, which will improve our quality of life, improve our health, reduce medical costs and slow climate change.

    I was incredulous when I read a column in the Chicago Tribune titled, “Who Owns the Wind?” subtitled, “We do, Wyoming says, and it’s taxing those who use it.” I mean, let’s be real! The reason for the tax which, trust me, will be argued and debated for a long time, is the loss of revenue from coal being produced in the Power River Basin (PRB) region.  The PRB is one of the largest coal producing regions in the world and tax revenue has helped balance the Wyoming budget for years. Now the PRB is running at about 40% of capacity, and this has hurt tax revenue significantly. I shared my frustration with Lee and Autumn, two pioneers in renewables who have been battling the odds for years and have become more and more cynical about America’s commitment to change. (Join the group!). The action by the Wyoming legislature pits tax revenue against environmental change. It just confirms that, at the end of the day, the almighty dollar rules and the hell with environmental change.

    Historically, train load after train load of coal moved daily out of the PRB region to utilities all over the US that were using coal-fired boilers. Every ton of coal was taxed. And, of course, PRB provided jobs.  Everyone was fat and happy except those who were affected by the noxious emissions of CO2, sulphur, mercury, chlorine, etc. And remember, at the same time, the coal industry was receiving substantial federal subsidies.  Irony of ironies – supporting an industry that ultimately increases the cost to the taxpayer because of increased health care issues.  The State of Wyoming theorized it owned the wind, and, like the PRB, it could capture tax revenue. Who owns the wind? What a great question. In my mind, it sure isn’t the State of Wyoming.

    Sadly, projects like the Choke Cherry and Sierra Madre that I mentioned in my last column may not happen because of this new tax. The tax makes the project in Wyoming less viable, and I suspect more friendly locations will be explored. The incongruity of all of this is Wyoming is losing an opportunity to be a leader in replacing fossil energy with renewables.

    A little further south there’s a completely different story. In Texas, of all places, renewables have grown very quickly. In a Wall Street Journal column, I was surprised to learn that the growth of renewables started in 1998 when then Governor George W. Bush (can you believe it?) overhauled the Texas power markets. He introduced a regulation plan that broke the grip of monopoly utilities that controlled generation, transmission and retail sales of electricity. He introduced competitive auctions for wholesale power. “Part of the plan was that there was an imposed government regulation/requirement that there must be at least 2,000 megawatts of renewable generating capacity by 2009. Texas achieved that in 2005 and Governor Rick Perry, who replaced Bush, raised the bar to 10,000 megawatts by 2025. Texas hit that goal in 2011. In April of this year, the state was generating more than 19,000 megawatts with more capacity to be added. That’s enough power for four million homes. Interestingly, Jimmy Glotfelty, Mr. Bush’s policy director, said, ‘climate change was not the driver for renewables. Rather it was a belief in free markets and entrepreneurs’.”

    The growth of renewables in Texas hasn’t come without debate: “Debate is raging between political parties over climate change, and critics charge that ‘green energy’ is little more than a government creation. Texas has taken an approach that works within the state’s free-market-based electricity system. State officials say wind and solar are almost certain to play a significant and growing role in the state’s energy future even when federal subsidies decline in coming years.”                     

    Then  there is the issue of subsidies.  Wind projects get hefty federal payouts whenever they generate electricity. At auctions, this means they can sometimes pay the state to take their electricity and still make money, undercutting the business model of fossil-fuel generators.

    So Bush and his team opened the market to deregulation and competition, and as a result renewables blossomed.

    Eat your heart out, Wyoming!

    The final column that caught my eye appeared in the International New York Times. It noted that for all our efforts to replace coal with renewables to meet goals that have, in some cases, been legislated, we need to be practical and make changes carefully. The author, Eduardo Porter, noted, “it won’t be easy to get rid of coal.” For example, Germany has a 2020 target to drastically cut emissions of CO2. Last year, it proposed a tax on lignite coal, also known as brown coal and really dirty. However, it’s also Germany’s main source of electricity. At the same time, Germany is phasing out nuclear energy. Between the loss of jobs in the coal industry and nuclear power, the tax became so controversial that the government had to pull back and replace it with a subsidy. It’s amazing the power that labor unions and local governments in coal regions have. Environmentalists were furious: “Instead of being fined for polluting by the proposed new climate levy, utilities will instead get paid for keeping their oldest and most inefficient lignite plants on standby,” noted a report on Germany’s energy policies by the environmental think-tank E3G for the nonprofit Oxfam. It “amounts to a golden handshake for utilities at the expense of taxpayers and consumers.” And that wasn’t all. The chancellery also rejected a push by Barbara Hendricks, the environment minister, to establish a road map to the total phase-out of coal, hoping to postpone timing decisions until after national elections next year.

    Germany has 65,000 organized coal workers, and they are very powerful. By comparison, America has 50,000. Mrs. Clinton says we’re going to shut the mines down, but we’ll give the industry $30 billion over 10 years. (Where’s that going to come from? Surely you know: us!). Mr. Trump is going to support the industry, at the expense of the environment. Who wins this one? (P.S., Trump doesn’t believe in global warming.)

    And the problem is, of course, worse in China. There are 2.5 million coal workers, and the government plans to cut 1.3 million coal jobs. I don’t think so. If this happens, there will be another revolution.
    The column concludes that it is going to be quite a while before coal disappears. “The world’s energy transition cannot be portrayed simply as ‘Big coal vs. vivacious wind and solar.’ Horrible as it might sound to economists – who believe in taxing polluters, not rewarding them – the energy transitions may require paying the dirtiest generators as Germany has done to stick around.

    Change, transition, is complex and like everything, patience, careful thinking and balance are required. Balance, that word balance again!

    Another Letter from the Earth.



    Calvin Frost is chairman of Channeled Resources Group, headquartered in Chicago, the parent company of Maratech International and GMC Coating. His email address is
    cfrost@channeledresources.com.

    Related Letters From The Earth

    • Sustainability

      A delicate balance

      I know I said I was going to write about “how to create a wasteless industry using renewable energy as the solution” in this issue.  However, I received an email from a reader requesting more detailed information on “carbon cyc…
      Calvin Frost 09.07.15

    • Sustainability

      Climate change, legal prostitution and the pine beetle

      Some of you may know that I live in Chicago. As a Midwestern transplant I read as much as possible about our region – its successes, cleaner Great Lakes, for example. And, its failures, stock piling petcoke, the by-product generated during the…
      Calvin Frost 07.21.15

    • Sustainability
      Capitalism combats pollution

      Capitalism combats pollution

      I didn’t get invited to The Wall Street Journal’s ECO:nomics Conference in Santa Barbara, CA, USA in March and I can’t figure out why. I’m the only voice of reason in the ongoing debate on “Emissons vs. Efficiency”…
      Calvin Front 06.03.15


    • Sustainability

      Trust me

      I love this: “All statements are true in some sense, false in some sense, meaningless in some sense, true and false in some sense, true and meaningless in some sense, false and meaningless in some sense and true and false and meaningless in som…
      Calvin Frost 04.16.15

    • Pressure Sensitive | Substrates | Sustainability

      What the Frack?

      I’d like to spend 24 hours with Susan Brantley and Anna Meyendorff.  Susan is a “distinguished” professor of Geosciences and Director of the Earth and Environmental Systems Institute at Pennsylvania University.  She is als…
      Calvin Frost 04.10.13


    Breaking News
    • Schreiner MediPharm develops smart label for Ypsomed
    • ID Label celebrates 25 years
    • Printeos Group goes digital with Durst Tau 330 RSC
    • Technicote names new national sales director
    • Xeikon Café Europe reveals Academy program
    View Breaking News >
    CURRENT ISSUE

    January/February 2019

    • Controlling Static
    • Spirits Labels
    • Digital Finishing
    • Metallic Effects Labels
    • Narrow Web Profile: Investing in the future at WS Packaging Group
    • View More >

    Cookies help us to provide you with an excellent service. By using our website, you declare yourself in agreement with our use of cookies.
    You can obtain detailed information about the use of cookies on our website by clicking on "More information”.

    • privacy policy
    • term and condition
    • about us
    • contact us

    follow us

    Subscribe

    magazines

    Image
    Image
    Image
    Image
    Image
    Image
    Image
    Image
    Image
    Image
    Image

    Copyright © 2019 Rodman Media. All rights reserved. Use of this constitutes acceptance of our privacy policy The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Rodman Media.

    AD BLOCKER DETECTED

    Our website is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors.
    Please consider supporting us by disabling your ad blocker.


    FREE SUBSCRIPTION Already a subscriber? Login