• Login
    • Join
  • Subscribe Free
    • Magazine
    • eNewsletter
    Checkout
    • Magazine
    • News
    • Exclusives
    • Labels & Packaging
    • Markets
    • Technology
    • Equipment
    • Supplies
    • Buyers' Guide
    • Events
    • Jobs
    • More
  • Magazine
  • News
  • Exclusives
  • Labels & Packaging
  • Markets
  • Technology
  • Equipment
  • Supplies
  • Buyers' Guide
  • Events
  • Jobs
  • Current / Back Issues
    Features
    Editorial
    Columns
    Digital Edition
    eNewsletter Archive
    Our Team
    Subscribe Now
    Advertise Now
    Top Features
    Digital and Hybrid Printers and Presses

    Digital Printing Market Update

    Overlamination Films

    Narrow Web Profile: Quality Tape & Label

    Companies To Watch: Arrow Systems, Inc.
    Breaking News
    Converter News
    European Label News
    Industry News
    Industry People
    M&A News
    New Products
    Expert's Opinion
    Live From Shows
    Top News
    Meech debuts remote monitoring product

    Label management system aids CBD brand

    New Polyonics label material helps metal processors avoid recalls

    Mactac gives back to local communities

    Avery Dennison receives APR recognition
    Blog
    Video Bites
    Beauty & Personal Care Labels
    Beer Labels
    Beverage Labels
    Flexible Packaging
    Folding Carton
    Food Labels
    Glue-Applied
    In-Mold
    Industrial Labels
    Medical Labels
    Pharmaceutical Labels
    Pressure Sensitive
    Prime Labels
    Promotional Labels
    Security Labels
    Shrink
    Smart Labels
    Specialty Labels
    Spirits Labels
    Wine Labels

    New Polyonics label material helps metal processors avoid recalls

    Mactac enhances spirits bottle label

    Designing returnable and reusable takeout packaging

    Western Shield improves efficiency with new Nilpeter FA-17

    UFlex doubling capacity of aseptic liquid packaging plant
    Africa
    Asia
    Australia
    China
    Europe
    India
    Latin America
    Middle East
    North America

    Label management system aids CBD brand

    Avery Dennison receives APR recognition

    Mactac enhances spirits bottle label

    Fathom Optics unleashes new technology targeting packaging industry

    Domino highlights virtual demo capabilities
    Flexography
    Digital Printing
    Prepress
    Finishing
    Sustainability

    Avery Dennison receives APR recognition

    Mondi wins eight 2021 WorldStar Packaging awards

    Bobst opens digital inkjet demo center in Barcelona

    Domino highlights virtual demo capabilities

    Product Identification Company launches flexo label printing capability
    Digital Printers & Presses
    Flexo Presses
    Label Converting Equipment
    Label Finishing Equipment
    Prepress Equipment

    Loftware and NiceLabel join forces

    Flint Group announces new XSYS division

    Bobst opens digital inkjet demo center in Barcelona

    Domino highlights virtual demo capabilities

    Bellissima DMS now available in India
    Dies And Tooling
    Flexo Supplies
    Ink & Coatings
    Prepress Supplies
    Pressrooom Supplies
    Substrates

    New Polyonics label material helps metal processors avoid recalls

    Mactac gives back to local communities

    Avery Dennison receives APR recognition

    Flint Group announces new XSYS division

    Mondi wins eight 2021 WorldStar Packaging awards
    All Companies
    Categories
    Company Profiles
    Label Converters
    Trade Associations
    Add New Company
    International Buyers Guide Companies
    Dantex Group

    NarrowWebExchange.com, LLC

    UPM Raflatac

    HP, Inc.

    Martin Automatic Inc.
    Industry Events
    Webinars
    Live from Show Events
    • Magazine
      • Current & Past Issues
      • Features
      • Editorial
      • Columns
      • Digital Edition
      • eNewsletter Archive
      • Subscribe Now
      • Advertise Now
    • Breaking News
    • Buyers' Guide
      • All Companies
      • Categories
      • Company Profiles
      • Label Converters
      • Trade Associations
      • Add Your Company
    • Labels & Packaging
      • Beauty & Personal Care Labels
      • Beer Labels
      • Beverage Labels
      • Flexible Packaging
      • Folding Carton
      • Food Labels
      • Glue-Applied
      • In-Mold
      • Industrial Labels
      • Medical Labels
      • Pharmaceuticals Labels
      • Pressure Sensitive
      • Prime Labels
      • Promotional Labels
      • Security Labels
      • Shrink
      • Smart Labels
      • Speciality Labels
      • Spirits Labels
      • Wine Tables
    • Markets
      • Africa
      • Asia
      • Australia
      • China
      • Europe
      • India
      • Latin America
      • Middle East
      • North America
    • Equipment
      • Digital Printers & Presses
      • Flexo Presses
      • Label Converting Equipment
      • Label Fishing Equipment
    • Supplies
      • Dies And Tooling
      • Flexo Supplies
      • Ink & Coatings
      • Prepress Supplies
      • Pressrooom Supplies
      • Substrates
    • Online Exclusives
    • Slideshows
    • Experts Opinions
    • Videos
    • Podcasts
    • Infographics
    • Blog
    • Whitepapers
    • Events
      • Industry Events
      • Live from Show Events
      • Webinars
    • Jobs
    • Resources
      • Supplier Gallery
      • Literature Showcase
      • Homepage Showcase
    • About Us
      • About Us
      • Contact Us
      • Advertise With Us
      • Privacy Policy
      • Terms of Use
    Front Row

    The shadow world of counterfeiting

    The bottom line is that we don’t know where or how big it is.

    Related CONTENT
    • Fathom Optics unleashes new technology targeting packaging industry
    • Flint Group announces new XSYS division
    • Alon Bar-Shany appointed chairman of Highcon Board
    • FPA publishes 'Flexible Packaging Path to a Circular Economy'
    • L&NW sits down with PPG's Amy Mercante
    Jack Kenny05.30.17
    A converter from New York once told me that a man with a foreign accent came to the plant one day and showed the receptionist a flexo plate. He asked if the company could use it to make labels for him. The employee, after examining the image on the plate, told him she would enquire within. She left the room, picked up a telephone and called the FBI. That guy was history. A savvy worker prevented the spread of counterfeit labels for a widely used pharmaceutical drug.

    Counterfeiting is big business. People say that the negative impact on global economies from fake products could be north of $600 billion. We’ll talk about the numbers further along, but it’s fair to say that the bad guys are pretty smart about getting their knock-offs into the supply chain, so much so that customs and other government officials the world over work full time to try to stop them.

    Counterfeiting is also a clumsy English word. It comes from Latin contra facere, which meant “to make in opposition or contrast, hence, in opposing imitation,” according to the Oxford English Dictionary. Over the centuries it moved from Old French to Norman to Old English, and by the time it got here somebody should have taken out the second “e”.

    I live in Connecticut, the third smallest US state. We were big counterfeiters back in the day, according to legend. For more than a century, the state’s unofficial nickname has been “The Nutmeg State.” Clever Yankee peddlers from Connecticut would travel up and down the Atlantic coast selling a myriad of wares, cures, tools and other home needs, including spices. The tale goes that a jar or a bucket of nutmegs would contain half of the little spice nuggets and half wooden balls of the same size. A good example of an alternative fact, perhaps.

    Labels are a subset of the packaging industry, and packaging is a subset of retail, commercial and industrial product markets. All of these are subsets of the counterfeiting industry. Labels and tags, it turns out, made up 2% (540) of all counterfeit seizures (28,092) in 2014 by the US Department of Homeland Security. Those product categories above labels were, in order from the largest seizures: wearing apparel and accessories, consumer electronics, pharmaceuticals and personal care, handbags and wallets, footwear, watches and jewelry, optical media, and computers and accessories.

    The value of those seizures is where this gets murky. Homeland Security came up with a value of $1.23 billion for the total, based entirely on manufacturers’ suggested retail prices. That’s the amount of money that the products – if they were legitimate – would have sold for at retail. (Few labels, of course, are sold by themselves to consumers.) The top three categories in the value list were watches/jewelry, handbags/wallets, and consumer electronics/parts.

    Counterfeiting is an ancient practice, according to Peggy Chaudhry and Alan Zimmerman in Protecting Your Intellectual Property Rights (2013). Creating bogus coins was a popular pastime in Roman times, they say, but product counterfeiting might even be older. “Babylonian and Egyptian priests placed inscriptions from earlier civilizations on monuments to increase their proceeds and legitimacy. The advent of trademarks used to identify manufacturers of particular products certainly created the opportunity for counterfeiting,” they wrote.

    During the Middle Ages, bakers put identifying marks in the crusts of their bread loaves, and still they were forged and sold with impunity. Counterfeit cacao beans entered the marketplace during Aztec rule in North America. Chinese art forgeries were noted in the 15th Century. An Englishman named Samuel Slater came to the new USA in 1789 and reproduced an entire British cotton mill from memory, to the alarm and chagrin of the English. Copying patents and trademarks was not yet illegal in the US at the time. Charles Dickens, wrote Chaudhry and Zimmerman, was irate to find copies of his works in Boston bookstores.

    The US government in 2008 estimated that counterfeiting was a $500 billion business. The International Anti-Counterfeiting Coalition said in 2012 that it was “a $600 billion a year problem. In fact, it’s a problem that has grown over 10,000% in the past two decades, in part fueled by consumer demand.”

    Quite a few sources dispute these figures, citing several reasons. “Since there is little agreement on definitions and serious problems of measurement, it is not really clear what the right number is,” wrote Chaudhry and Zimmerman. It is difficult to measure because it is illegal, occupying the shadow world of organized crime.

    The only measurable data to compute into a value are the reports of seizures of counterfeit products. Surely that’s a fraction of the total; the size of that fraction is unknowable. Nobody agrees on the other factors that might go into the calculation. “Should the estimate include sales lost by specific brands and at what prices, damage to brand equity, total sales of counterfeits, or some combination of these factors?” the researchers asked.

    The US General Accountability Office says that commonly cited figures for counterfeit products come from the FBI and the Customs and Border Protection Service. But the FBI has said it doesn’t have source data on the problem, and Customs didn’t know where its figures came from.

    Methods of figuring the scope of the counterfeiting business include extrapolation from seizures, surveys of supply and demand, use of economic multipliers, and the “rule of thumb,” say Chaudhry et al. “Each of these methods faces daunting challenges to accuracy and none can be relied upon.

    “Some economists even question the idea that there are losses associated with counterfeiting.”

    Well, sorry. We know that there are losses, starting with fake drugs, which hurt and kill innocent people. “Overall, global estimates of drug counterfeiting are ambiguous, depending on region, but proportions range from 1% of sales in developed countries to more than 10% in developing countries. In specific regions in Africa, Asia and Latin America, chances of purchasing a counterfeit drug may be higher than 30%.” That’s from Michael Green of the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

    Throughout the decades that I have been studying the packaging industry, I’ve wondered many times about the people who run businesses to deliberately falsify information, containers and ingredients. Their motive is apparent, but what are the mechanics of the operation?

    Where do they buy narrow web and wide web presses, dies, platemaking systems, inks, rewinders and substrates? Do they walk the aisles of Labelexpo? How do they get the finished fakes into the legitimate product stream in such vast quantities? How are they not caught?

    Several times I thought about trying to locate one of these companies, set up a clandestine, way off-the-record meeting, disguise its identity, and publish the answers that everyone would like to know. Those were fleeting thoughts, for two good reasons: I’d probably spend the rest of my life behind bars for breaking a host of laws, and I don’t fancy being fitted for cement shoes.

    The packaging industry spends big money fighting counterfeit products, and so do all the others who are victims of the dark art. Security measures are well established, and new ones are developed year by year. They work, but the bad guys find ways around them. The struggle continues, but there is so much that we just don’t know.



    The author is president of Jack Kenny Media, a communications firm specializing in the packaging industry, and is the former editor of L&NW magazine. He can be reached by email –at jackjkenny@gmail.com.
    Related Searches
    • plate
    • presses
    • flexo
    • tags
    Suggested For You
    Food Safety and Digital Printing Food Safety and Digital Printing
    Fathom Optics unleashes new technology targeting packaging industry Fathom Optics unleashes new technology targeting packaging industry
    Flint Group announces new XSYS division Flint Group announces new XSYS division
    Alon Bar-Shany appointed chairman of Highcon Board Alon Bar-Shany appointed chairman of Highcon Board
    FPA publishes FPA publishes 'Flexible Packaging Path to a Circular Economy'
    L&NW sits down with PPG L&NW sits down with PPG's Amy Mercante
    Outlook Group formalizes environmental policy Outlook Group formalizes environmental policy
    L&NW L&NW's most read features in 2020
    Bobst commits to digital future Bobst commits to digital future
    L&NW’s top headlines of 2020 L&NW’s top headlines of 2020
    Esko honored with philanthropy award from ISU Esko honored with philanthropy award from ISU
     Resource Label Group acquires Labels West Resource Label Group acquires Labels West
    FPA updates Flexible Packaging Market Tracker, adds COVID-19 data FPA updates Flexible Packaging Market Tracker, adds COVID-19 data
    MacDermid names Zech Corcimiglia senior account manager MacDermid names Zech Corcimiglia senior account manager
    Bobst announces a new organizational structure Bobst announces a new organizational structure

    Related Front Row

    • What will tomorrow bring?

      Today’s challenges are sudden and relentless.
      Jack Kenny 06.04.20

    • Planning for recovery

      When the virus abates, how will you rebuild?
      Jack Kenny 04.03.20

    • Fun facts about packaging

      Fun facts about packaging

      Impress your friends and colleagues with these industry gems.
      Jack Kenny 03.05.20


    • What’s trending?

      Trends teach us how to think, sell and profit.
      Jack Kenny 01.31.20

    • Labels, legislation and cannabis

      ...
      Jack Kenny 11.15.19

    • The innovative leader

      Build the team, then let it run.
      Jack Kenny 10.11.19


    • Is it first?

      An effective safety program reaches into all areas of a business.
      Jack Kenny 09.06.19

    • The patch: an intimate look

      A converting challenge, transdermal patches continue to evolve.
      Jack Kenny 07.10.19

    • Blog yourself

      Taking online communication to the next level.
      Jack Kenny 05.31.19


    • The value of research in label design

      Analyze and capitalize on the customer’s proclivities.
      Jack Kenny 04.05.19

    • How to lose a sale

      The experts get right to the point about mistakes.
      Jack Kenny 03.14.19

    • The sword and the substrate

      China’s restrictions on recyclable waste are bad and good for business.
      Jack Kenny 02.01.19


    • Weed labels

      ...
      Jack Kenny 11.16.18

    • Color and packaging

      There’s more to color than ink.
      Jack Kenny 10.12.18

    • Working the show

      There’s more to Labelexpo than strolling the aisles.
      Jack Kenny 09.10.18


    Trending
    • Fathom Optics Unleashes New Technology Targeting Packaging Industry
    • Alon Bar-Shany Appointed Chairman Of Highcon Board
    • L&NW Sits Down With PPG's Amy Mercante
    • Avery Dennison Receives APR Recognition
    • Flint Group Announces New XSYS Division
    Breaking News
    • Exhibitor registration opens for virtual.drupa
    • FTA planning in-person Forum & INFOFLEX
    • Fortis Solutions Group achieves SGP certification
    • Baldwin's Ahlbrandt unveils corona treatment product
    • Meech debuts remote monitoring product
    View Breaking News >
    CURRENT ISSUE

    November/December 2020

    • Digital and Hybrid Printers and Presses
    • Digital Printing Market Update
    • Overlamination Films
    • Narrow Web Profile: Quality Tape & Label
    • View More >

    Cookies help us to provide you with an excellent service. By using our website, you declare yourself in agreement with our use of cookies.
    You can obtain detailed information about the use of cookies on our website by clicking on "More information”.

    • About Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms And Conditions
    • Contact Us

    follow us

    Subscribe
    Nutraceuticals World

    Latest Breaking News From Nutraceuticals World

    BGG Obtains U.S. Patent on AstaZine Natural Astaxanthin for Heart Function During Exercise
    Qualitas Health/iwi Raises $10 Million in Investment Round
    Aker BioMarine Expands Krill Portfolio with Novel Protein Hydrolysate
    Coatings World

    Latest Breaking News From Coatings World

    Huntsman Finalizes Acquisition of Gabriel Performance Products
    PPG Completes COLORFUL COMMUNITIES Project at School in A. Bangsaothong Samutprakarn, Thailand
    dar-tech, inc. Becomes U.S. Midwestern Distributor for ZS Interpolymer
    Medical Product Outsourcing

    Latest Breaking News From Medical Product Outsourcing

    FineHeart Successfully Tests Wireless TET System
    Apria Healthcare Settles Whistleblower Lawsuit
    OraSure’s OMNIgene·ORAL Device Included in COVID-19 EUA Amendment
    Contract Pharma

    Latest Breaking News From Contract Pharma

    Valeo Pharma Appoints President, COO
    Metrion, LifeArc Extend Neuroscience Alliance
    Grifols Begins COVID-19 Plasma Treatment Trial
    Beauty Packaging

    Latest Breaking News From Beauty Packaging

    JLo Beauty Launches at Sephora & Amazon
    Unilever and Alibaba Group Join Forces
    Redken Unveils Acidic Bonding Concentrate Range
    Happi

    Latest Breaking News From Happi

    A Surge in Interest for Supplements & Vitamins
    Manscaped Expands Further in Europe
    Color Street Gives Back
    Ink World

    Latest Breaking News From Ink World

    dar-tech, inc. Becomes U.S. Midwestern Distributor for ZS Interpolymer
    Techkon USA, Konica Minolta Partner
    Alon Bar-Shany Appointed Chairman of Highcon Board
    Label & Narrow Web

    Latest Breaking News From Label & Narrow Web

    Exhibitor registration opens for virtual.drupa
    FTA planning in-person Forum & INFOFLEX
    Fortis Solutions Group achieves SGP certification
    Nonwovens Industry

    Latest Breaking News From Nonwovens Industry

    Super Strong Inks Survive Tough Environments
    Ontex Honored for Mask Production
    TFP Acquires PV3 Technologies
    Orthopedic Design & Technology

    Latest Breaking News From Orthopedic Design & Technology

    OrthoPediatrics Expands Agent Network in Three European Countries
    Studies Show FlareHawk Expandable Cage Delivers Favorable Fusion, Patient Outcomes
    Rapid Recovery Protocol Can Lead to Increased Range of Motion After TKA
    Printed Electronics Now

    Latest Breaking News From Printed Electronics Now

    UDC Subsidiary Adesis' Website Wins 2020 MarCom Platinum Award
    Roadsimple Modernizes Warehouse Ops with Zebra Technologies
    Graphene Flagship Launches Redesigned Website

    Copyright © 2021 Rodman Media. All rights reserved. Use of this constitutes acceptance of our privacy policy The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Rodman Media.

    AD BLOCKER DETECTED

    Our website is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors.
    Please consider supporting us by disabling your ad blocker.


    FREE SUBSCRIPTION Already a subscriber? Login