Breaking News

DuPont is denied request for preliminary injunction against MacDermid

November 24, 2008

The decision is part of a 2006 photopolymer plate patent infringement lawsuit in which DuPont sought a preliminary injunction against certain MacDermid thermally developed flexographic printing products.

MacDermid, a specialty chemicals company headquartered in Denver, CO, USA, has announced that for the second time the Federal District Court in New Jersey has denied DuPont’s motion for a preliminary injunction. A preliminary injunction is used in order to restrain a party from going forward with a course of conduct until the case has been decided.

The decision is part of a 2006 photopolymer plate patent infringement lawsuit in which DuPont sought a preliminary injunction against certain MacDermid thermally developed flexographic printing products. MacDermid markets its thermal equipment under the LAVA trade name.

In its rulings, the court found that MacDermid has raised enough questions regarding whether the ‘859 patent (DuPont’s US Patent No 6,773,859) is invalid and that DuPont failed to show that MacDermids claim that the patent is invalid is unwarranted. The court concluded that there are substantial questions regarding whether the ‘859 patent was an “obvious combination of elements in the prior art.” According to US patent law, an invention must meet certain minimum requirements to be protected by a US patent. For example, to qualify for patent protection, an invention must be new and different from what has been known, used or described in the past.

Michael Siegmund, president, MacDermid Printing Solutions, says, “MacDermid is a technology-based company that makes a considerable investment in R&D. Our philosophy, culture and business practices are such that we would not, and do not, knowingly infringe any valid patent.”

Scot Benson, vice president, sales, added, “This has been our stance from the beginning. We were very confident that the court would continue to uphold our position; and they have.”  
  • HP previews Dscoop

    HP previews Dscoop

    Greg Hrinya, Associate Editor||February 10, 2017
    Ken Brown detailed the event, which will take place in Phoenix, AZ, USA, from March 1-4.

  • Xeikon Café returns in March

    Xeikon Café returns in March

    February 10, 2017
    Members of all areas of the label and packaging industry are invited to Xeikon headquarters in Lier, Belgium, March 28-31.

  • RotoMetrics tackles rotary diecutting challenges

    RotoMetrics tackles rotary diecutting challenges

    Greg Hrinya, Associate Editor||February 7, 2017
    Customers are seeking higher quality with shorter lead times.

  • Getting Educated at Labelexpo

    Getting Educated at Labelexpo

    Steve Katz, Editor||September 7, 2016
    With a wide range of presentations, expert-led master classes and machinery demonstrations, there is no shortage of learning

  • Anilox Cleaning Equipment

    Anilox Cleaning Equipment

    Steve Katz, Editor||July 15, 2016
    Machinery manufacturers are dedicated to making sure the “heart of flexo” is well maintained.

  • Narrow Web Profile:  Dion Label Printing

    Narrow Web Profile: Dion Label Printing

    Steve Katz, Editor||July 15, 2016
    Diversity and dedication to quality are the hallmarks of this Massachusetts-based label company.